Best Pizza in Punxsutawney

Anthony Says, "Think About Pizza!"

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Cheese Pizza (X-Large - 16" (12 Slice))

Add Item

Cheese Pizza (The Chief - 24" X 12" (18 Slice))

Add Item

Chicken Wings

Add Item

Our Bourbon BBQ Pizza! 🍕🧀

Indulge your taste buds at our culinary haven with a must-try favorite: the Bourbon BBQ Pizza. Picture this – grilled chicken generously basted in our signature Stello's Bourbon BBQ sauce, harmoniously layered with crisp onions, sweet peppers, and a generous blanket of cheddar. It's a flavor symphony that promises to elevate your pizza experience to new heights.

Try Our Chicken Rancher Pizza!

Our Chicken Rancher Pizza is another crowd-pleaser, featuring the perfect medley of our succulent chicken tossed in our buttermilk ranch, bacon, tomatoes, and 100% real cheddar cheese. Prepare for a taste sensation that's nothing short of extraordinary.

Cheesy Bread Bliss 🥟🧀🍖🍅

Craving a delightful starter? Look no further than our Cheesy Bread, crafted fresh to order with our in-house blend of authentic Italian cheeses. We uphold the Italian tradition of simplicity, ensuring each bite is a celebration of quality and flavor. When you choose our dishes, you're not just savoring exceptional taste; you're investing in our community. Buying local keeps your money in Punxsutawney!

Tradition and Dedication

We take pride in sourcing the finest ingredients, from our fresh-packed sauce (never a concentrate) to our 100% authentic Italian cheeses. Join us in preserving tradition while relishing the unmatched culinary experience that Stello's brings to your table. Your satisfaction is not just our goal – it's our tradition.

Punxsutawney's Premier Dining Experience

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

ORDER NOW!

Family Owned and Operated

Serving Punxsutawney the very best authentic Italian pizza and specialty hoagies. Feast with us today. All of our meals are handmade with the finest ingredients and baked to perfection. You'll love our hand tossed dough, made with a high protein flour and our authentic chunky pizza sauce, inspired by the artistry of neighborhood pizzaioli (pizza-makers) throughout Italy. Made from a traditional blend of fresh red-ripe tomatoes, extra-virgin olive oil, garlic, and herbs.

Our pizzas are topped with 100% natural cheeses; our special blend of whole milk mozzarella and creamy provolone cheeses, and then layered with the freshest selection of your favorite meats & vegetables. Whether it's a personal size Papoos or The CHIEF we have the right size for your family. Call 814-938-8132 right now and let our experienced pizzaioli at Punxsy Pizza serve you the tastiest pizza in town. Guaranteed to Satisfy! If we can't make it right, we'll give you your money back!

Punxsy Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Join Punxsy Pizza Rewards

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Fantastic pizza - great service - relaxed atmosphere. So happy we stopped here during our visit to Punxy.

Mancil G.

Best pizza in Punxsutawney hands down. I have tried just about everything on the menu... Some of the specialty pizzas are a must try. The taco pizza, pierogi pizza, punxaroni & the chicken rancher are all amazing. And DEFINITELY try the calzones!